The city has
always been in the back of my mind over the years and while the passion of the
time may have faded some, my interest in the city and area never really has
gone away. So when I decided to take this trip one of the places I guaranteed
myself I would go was Sarajevo and I am glad that I came.
Seeing the
area first hand just reinforces my disgust for the Bosnian Serb soldiers who simply
killed and destroyed everything they came across. From what I have seen and
heard, it was as horrible as reported and probably even worse. There is no real
justification for the way the acted during the war and it even makes less sense
when you consider that they wanted Bosnia and prized the city for a “greater
Serbia” and eventually annex into Serbia itself. But they went about it in a
way similar to Sherman’s march to the sea through South Carolina, in that they
killed and terrorized everybody and left almost nothing standing. But I don’t
think even Sherman’s march through South Carolina was as brutal and senseless
as what the Bosnian Serbs did to the local population. It is even worse when
you consider that they were friends and neighbors of the people they killed
only a year before the war. Sherman was not friends with the people whose homes
he burned and he did not indiscriminately kill men, women and children. Some of
my southern friends may take issue with that but this is about Bosnia, not
Sherman.
Bosnia has
never fully recovered from the war and is behind the other countries in the
region. Croatia has done a good job fixing the damage and moving on but their
war only lasted for around 1 year before they pushed the Serbs out, probably mostly
into Bosnia. My guide, Samer, told me that Bosnia used to be the industrial
capital of the former Yugoslavia and they made furniture, cars, airplanes, and
all sorts of things here before the war. But all of that collapsed and was
destroyed by the war and even today they have no real industry. There are also
large areas of the country that are largely empty of people, either because
they were either driven or killed off or that any opportunities there have been
completely destroyed. The north is particularly this way and from what Samer
told me, Croatia has similar issues in the northern part of the country.
Mostar abouta year after the war ended.
Mostar about
The area is
also largely forgotten by the world community today as there are new wars to
deal with, so there is no more money to continue reconstruction. In
Sarajevo and Mostar, just about every building was damaged and the money to
repair them has often come from outside the country. For example Qatar built a
big library for Sarajevo in the Old Town. For that matter all of the Trams in
Sarajevo were destroyed and what you see today were donated by other cities from their old and rusting trains.
The
historical buildings need to be rebuilt in the same way as before the war,
which is not cheap, and the money to do this is largely gone so the buildings
still damaged stay that way. Also once you get out of the old parts of the city
the damage is even more prevalent. Sarajevo is in better shape than other
communities, for example Mostar still has bombed out buildings mixed in with
the repaired ones at a rate greater than Sarajevo. But even Mostar is a big
city and the smaller ones in the country sometimes sit largely abandoned.
The peace
agreement in Bosnia left in place that anybody could return indefinitely to
their former property. This is good but at the same time creates other problems
as there is property where the residents are gone so it sits abandoned and
bombed out indefinitely too.
The grave
yards are all full here too with new white grave markers packed in. While stuck
in the traffic jam while trying to exit Sarajevo one of the large cemeteries
was off to my right. I was struck by just how many gleaming white headstones covered
the hillside, compared to the old stones, and how tightly packed in they were. There
are ever present reminders of the war that you can’t escape. Pre and post war sections of one cemetery in Sarajevo
The war in
Bosnia was particularly brutal and it is hard for me to comprehend how a
population could turn on itself so quickly and brutally. It is very reminiscent
of how the Nazi’s and Germans turned on the Jewish population in the 1930’s and
how it extended beyond just the politicians but was tolerated
and participated in by the community as a whole. The violence here was
particularly brutal and I would say was full of personal vendetta. It was not
simply a war with killing, it was ethnic cleansing at its worst and has left
indelible scars on both the landscape and the people that will likely take
another generation to fully heal.
The people I
have met here don’t really talk much about the war, if anything I get the
impression that everybody just wants to forget. For example the 50 something
guy I met one night at a restaurant that talked about how he lived in L.A. for
10 years, starting in 1993, but not explaining why he moved there. He returned to Sarajevo for
“sentimental reasons.” Also from what Samer told me about how the people of
Sarajevo would not go up into the forests around the city until very recently
out of the memory of what the Bosnian Serbs did up there.
Not that I
can blame them, it is almost like post traumatic syndrome where people just
want to black it all out, not so easy to do when you have buildings with bullet
holes or totally bombed out and still have land mine warning signs.
I have also
notices that I don’t really see many locals my own age here, everybody seems to
be 35 or younger or 55 and older. In that respect it seems almost that an
entire generation of Bosnia has either been killed or moved away and never
returned. Gen X here does not really exist and I suspect that once they left
most have never returned. On my way into the city I talked with one guy around
my age who now lives in Zurich but “is a Bosnian at heart”. He did not tell me
but I pieced together that he left Sarajevo during the war, I’m sure as a
refugee in his 20's. He does business in Sarajevo but does not live there any more.
But as sad as
some things are, there are other things that are hopeful too. For instance
there seems to be a large population 35 and under that were children at the
time of the war or born afterwards. In fact I would say there are a lot of
people here in their 20’s, possibly Bosnia’s own Baby Boomer generation. There
also has been a lot of reconstruction here. When you see pictures of Sarajevo or
Mostar in 1995, everything had been devastated and it is amazing to see how
much change has occurred in 20 years. While there are still a lot of reminders,
there has been a lot of reconstruction and new construction as well. Buildings
still show the scars but they are back in use for the most part, amazing given
the condition most were in. The tourist population has also slowly started to
increase too as Bosnia slowly gets back onto the radar of Europeans. However,
as Samer told me, there is still the concern of safety in the region that has
been Green Visions biggest challenge in getting people to come in to visit.
I have also
heard stories about Bosnian Serbs who would not take part in all the killing
that occurred and actually fought back alongside the Bosnians to try and repel
them. This must have put a big price on their heads and I am sure the Bosnian
Serbs looked on them as traitors. This is not something I really knew about and
it is good to hear that even in the darkest times some people do the right
thing in the face of it all.
What I have
found here is a city and nation that is slowly on the mend. There are still deep scars
that may never heal as long as there are people who were alive at the same
time, but there is also a new generation of Bosnians who have little or no
recollection of the war and things are moving forward giving hope for the
future.
The people of
Sarajevo also seem to be slowly reclaiming their city and taking back the
places that they once enjoyed before the war but have stayed away from since.
I leave with
some mixed feelings. I still have a resentment for Bosnian Serbs and the Serb
government and the horrendous things they did here. Watching video of the war at the museums is horrifying and stirs old feelings. At the same time I have
less of a resentment to Bosnian Serbs and have to remember to
look at them as individuals and not stereotype them all. How to
understand the roots of something like this are important to ensure it does not
repeat itself in the future but I also recognize that people have been trying to understand this kind of thing since WWII and likely long before that. The war seemed to be based in nationalistic
ambitions and petty grievances that the conflict allowed individuals to take
advantage of.
All of the mosques were destroyed but have since been rebuilt. The destruction was indiscriminant and all the Christian and Jewish churches were targeted and destroyed too.
I can't find any before pictures but the Gazi Husrev Beg's Mosque in Old Town was heavily damaged during the war but has been fully rebuilt today.
All of the mosques were destroyed but have since been rebuilt. The destruction was indiscriminant and all the Christian and Jewish churches were targeted and destroyed too.
I can't find any before pictures but the Gazi Husrev Beg's Mosque in Old Town was heavily damaged during the war but has been fully rebuilt today.
I don’t really understand it any better than before but recognize that not everybody
acts this way and that given the right set of circumstances, the United States
would not be above this. I would like to think that there is no way this could happen
in America but it does seem that this type of thing has a habit of repeating
itself and that the people who perpetrate this are not so easy to identify as
criminals but are normal people who get caught up in the conflict and loose
themselves and their sense of right and wrong. Perhaps this can help explain why when there is rioting in Ferguson, Baltimore, New York, South Carolina, and so on, there is this group think that happens and people who would never riot get caught up in everything.
Before the war here everybody lived together very well and turned on themselves overnight. The same can probably be said about Germans during WWII and one can possibly say the same about the average Japanese too. I am not so sure that Americans are that different and it seems that the right set of circumstances can set off the worst in humanity. Something to remember as we practice or politics of discourse with each other.
It is hard to see in the photo but Sarajevo from a distance looks like most any other city today, you don't see the scars until you get up close.
Before the war here everybody lived together very well and turned on themselves overnight. The same can probably be said about Germans during WWII and one can possibly say the same about the average Japanese too. I am not so sure that Americans are that different and it seems that the right set of circumstances can set off the worst in humanity. Something to remember as we practice or politics of discourse with each other.
It is hard to see in the photo but Sarajevo from a distance looks like most any other city today, you don't see the scars until you get up close.
No comments:
Post a Comment